Rank Forever Keepers

[virgonomic]

14 team mixed 5x5 H2H

I have the 10th pick in round 19 with rounds 19-22 eligible as "keep forever" backfilled from round 22.

My keepers:

Rounds 1-4: Yellich Baez Merrifield JRamirez
Rounds 20-22: Tatis Strasburg Franco

Who are the top 10 from the following list?

Rutschman
Mize
Pearson
Witt Jr
Kelenic
Luzardo
Pache
Bart
BMcKay
AVaughn
Whitley
Kieboom
DMay

[virgonomic]

Draft is tomorrow at 1PM EST, BTW.

[ssmallz]

Vaughn and Kelenic would be my clear top 2 - it's keep forever and favor hitters over pitchers. After that I'd probably go Rushman then Bart. Catchers are nice but they get injured, then it's a toss up (Mize, Luzardo, Pearson, McKay, Whitley) all potential injury concern

[chancellor]

Here's my thoughts; on talent, Whitley should be higher but I can't justify moving him up.

Vaughn
Rutschmann
Kelenic
~
DMay
Bart
Mize
Luzardo
Kieboom
~
Whitley
McKay
Witt, jr.

[Ken]

Interesting, I'm curious about the relative values in H2H, I think that skews the values more back towards pitchers.

[chancellor]

Interesting, I'm curious about the relative values in H2H, I think that skews the values more back towards pitchers.

Valid question; I thought about putting May up in the top tier for that reason.

[mjl]

Chance's list looks reasonable. I might have Cal Abrams Jr somewhere in the middle group if he's available which I assume he is.

[virgonomic]

Chance's list looks reasonable. I might have Cal Abrams Jr somewhere in the middle group if he's available which I assume he is.

Apparently he goes by CJ. I think I left him off bc I already have Tatis and Franco.

[virgonomic]

Severino and Sale will probably be drafted in the 19th round. I don't think they will fall to me. If they do I'm not sure I have the stomach to draft one and take a 0 for a year+ with Franco already on my roster.