I would think that you just have to have a rule and stick to it with everyone so it is fair. Sure, Sale got hurt before the season started, but what about the guy who spends $60 on deGrom if deGrom gets hurt after your auction? There has to be an arbitrary deadline. It can be the keeper list submit date, it can be draft day, or somewhere in between, but for fairness sake, it has to be set in stone and the same for everyone.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Chris Sale: TJ Surgery
Collapse
X
-
Thanks guys. I decided to let the guy replace Sale with another player and adjusted his team budget to reflect the $60 difference in cost. Just trying to be fair. That's a tough hole to climb out of and would have sunk his season as long as it doesn't get canceled. Someone else may be in the same situation some day so this new rule will benefit everyone going forward if a keeper player has a season ending injury before the draft. Everyone in my league seems to be ok with it.“Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.”
― Albert Einstein
Comment
-
Originally posted by madducks View PostThanks guys. I decided to let the guy replace Sale with another player and adjusted his team budget to reflect the $60 difference in cost. Just trying to be fair. That's a tough hole to climb out of and would have sunk his season as long as it doesn't get canceled. Someone else may be in the same situation some day so this new rule will benefit everyone going forward if a keeper player has a season ending injury before the draft. Everyone in my league seems to be ok with it.
I understand you are trying to be fair, but fair would be affording the same options to all teams, not just one. Basically you are saying that his decision to keep Sale is okay to roll back, but what about other teams, why can't they roll back a previous bad decision?
The only way to work through this is something that is equitable for all, not just to accommodate one team.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ken View PostThis is not at all intended as a criticism of you, but to give perspective. If I saw that in my league and every owner was not also afforded the right to swap keepers (basically changing the keeper deadline), this would be my last year in that league.
I understand you are trying to be fair, but fair would be affording the same options to all teams, not just one. Basically you are saying that his decision to keep Sale is okay to roll back, but what about other teams, why can't they roll back a previous bad decision?
The only way to work through this is something that is equitable for all, not just to accommodate one team.“Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.”
― Albert Einstein
Comment
-
Originally posted by madducks View PostNone of the other keepers are going to miss the entire season. Unless it gets canceled of course.
Unless your constitution specifically says you can do this, this is the wrong decision in my opinion. You are trying to be nice, which is certainly a great thing, but it should be unilateral and not just one situation. You are worried because he paid so much salary towards one player but that was the risk he took on.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ken View PostWhat if they are though? Was the Mancini owner given the same option? And why is specifically the entire season the only length necessary. Was the Verlander owner given the same option? And the Severino owner? Were owners of TJ pitchers given extra resources in past years?
Originally posted by Ken View PostUnless your constitution specifically says you can do this, this is the wrong decision in my opinion. You are trying to be nice, which is certainly a great thing, but it should be unilateral and not just one situation. You are worried because he paid so much salary towards one player but that was the risk he took on.“Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.”
― Albert Einstein
Comment
-
Originally posted by Gregg View PostSales went to a rebuilder in our 12 team AL 5x5 for $17.
Severino went for 11 to the same owner.
Comment
Comment