Max Muncy extension in 9-team NL-only

[whalewang]

Last year, Max hit 35 HRs, 101 Runs, 98 RBIs, and .251 AVE in 487 ABs,

9-team NL-only keeper league; $260 budget. Categories are Runs, RBIs, SB, HRs, AVE.

Should I extend my $10 Max Muncy?

Details: Max is in his last year at $10 (3 of 3 years) but I can extend him 4 years to $15 (for 2020), $20 (for 2021), $25, and $30. The cost to drop a contract is insignificant (it cost only $5 real money and doesn't affect our fantasy budget). Also, I'll be playing him at 1st/CI and not 2nd if that really matters much.

[Judge Jude]

he's 29 years old, and if they suddenly change the ball, he might turn back into Max Muncy.

if these are your only two options, take the profit at $10 and move on. really helps in 3 categories, really doesn't in the other 2.

[Ken]

No extension. 9 team league is relatively shallow, so I'd only be extending stars.

[Gregg]

I agree with both Judge and Ken here. Play him out.