12-team mixed keeper decisions

[DMT]

12-team mixed 5x5 with OBA & Slug replacing BA & HR, and W+QS instead of Ws. B contracts can be extended for +$5/year. TIA

Gleyber 4B (thinking 2 years --> 14 thru 2022)
T Anderson 2B (not planning to extend)
E Escobar 6A
Devers 15A
Soto 18B (extend 1 or 2 years?)
Kepler 2A
Meadows 5A
Flaherty 2B (thinking 2 years)
Woodruff 1A
~~~~~~
Options for final keeper
Kershaw 25A
JD Davis 8A
Neris 7A
Bradley 5A
Manaea 5A
Gallen 15A

[virgonomic]

With all that value, I'd give Kershaw a long look. I think he's worth the gamble at 25.

JD Davis is a nice value as well. Manaea is a nice value at 5 as well but I think I'd rather have Kershaw for $20 more.

I assume Bradley is Archie?

So, GTMH I go with Kershaw, but wouldn't fault you for going with Davis or Manaea.

Gleyber 4B (thinking 2 years --> 14 thru 2022) I could see going 3. 2 years will return a huge profit and lessen the risk.
Soto 18B (extend 1 or 2 years?) I'd go one.
Flaherty 2B (thinking 2 years) Sure, but no more.

[Ken]

12 team mixed is pretty shallow which makes my choices very focused on high end talent. Value plays for more marginal players are not in consideration for me when you have this type list. So for me, JD Davis is out. I'd go with Kershaw.

[revo]

I'd extend Gleyber, Soto & Flaherty 2 years apiece. I would extend Anderson a year.

$25 seems fair value for Kershaw, so I think I'd lean towards Manaea who was tremendous down the stretch.