SP Rank

[DMT]

How would you rank these three ROS?

Gibson
Peacock
Cease

[Gregg]

Cease

Peacock

Gibson

Might put Cease under Peacock for the rest of the year but I pick Cease afterwards.

[virgonomic]

Peacock
Cease
~~~~~
Gibson

It's close. Cease/Peacock is a coin flip for me. GTMH I go with Peacock since Cease could struggle his second time through the league.

[Ken]

I don’t think there is necessarily a right or wrong answer here. These guys seem like they are all on the same tier and all have their warts.

I’m surprised by all the peacock love. He has been average this year and it seems to me that there is always risk of moving to the pen.

[virgonomic]

I don’t think there is necessarily a right or wrong answer here. These guys seem like they are all on the same tier and all have their warts.

I’m surprised by all the peacock love. He has been average this year and it seems to me that there is always risk of moving to the pen.

He had a 3.20 ERA prior to his last 4 starts pre-DL. It was 3.62 prior to his last start which added 0.5. His ERA is 1.15 now and oddly Baseball Reference doesn't show WHIP in the game log but I remember it being 1.11 when I traded him in one league a month ago. He's having a fine season. You are right that his innings may be limited.

[Ken]

He had a 3.20 ERA prior to his last 4 starts pre-DL. It was 3.62 prior to his last start which added 0.5. His ERA is 1.15 now and oddly Baseball Reference doesn't show WHIP in the game log but I remember it being 1.11 when I traded him in one league a month ago. He's having a fine season. You are right that his innings may be limited.

But last start happened, and if we could just remove starts from every pitcher the results would be similar.

[virgonomic]

But last start happened, and if we could just remove starts from every pitcher the results would be similar.

Sure, but every pitcher is not in this discussion.