Belt/Desmond/GPolanco

[swampdragon]

Rank these three for rest of season
Hits
Runs
Hr
RBIs
SB (yes it does)
Avg
Oba

Cutting one now
Cutting another when/if AHicks comes back

[pitbull]

Does your league count SB? Desmond is capable of 15-20.

With SB

Desmond
Polanco
Belt

Without SB then

Polanco
Belt
Desmond

[revo]

Polanco
desmond
Belt

[harmon]

Polanco
Belt
Desmond

[Ken]

Polanco
Desmond
Belt

[Sour Masher]

Are these rankings in order of best to worst or first cut to last? For me, Belt is my first cut, because he is an injury waiting to happen.

[cavebird]

They seem close to me since seven hitting cats reduces the value of Desmond's steals. I would think that positional considerations should make the decision given how close they are.

[Ken]

Are these rankings in order of best to worst or first cut to last? For me, Belt is my first cut, because he is an injury waiting to happen.

Best to worst

[swampdragon]

thanks guys - Belt is gone for now

still waiting on Ohtani and Hicks to come back - then will need to review - Ideally I would make a 2 for one trade but those are much harder to pull off

[swampdragon]

Its back again

cut one
Desmond
Piscotty
Pederson
maybe Inciarte (but then steals might be an issue)

I am leading in steals so dont factor it in
runs, hrs, rbis, Sb, AVG, OBA

I need the most help in HRs and RBIs and avg

leaning towards giving up on Desmond -

[swampdragon]

Its back again

cut one
Desmond
Piscotty
Pederson
GPolanco
probably not cutting Inciarte (but then steals might be an issue)

I am leading in steals so dont factor it in
runs, hrs, rbis, Sb, AVG, OBA

I need the most help in HRs and RBIs and avg

leaning towards giving up on Desmond -

[pitbull]

I would say Desmond as if he doesn't pick it up soon Tapia will continue to not only steal his AB but could force Desmond into a 4th OF. Certainly hope not as I have Desmond too but dude cannot get it going.

[revo]

Its back again

cut one
Desmond
Piscotty
Pederson
GPolanco
probably not cutting Inciarte (but then steals might be an issue)

I am leading in steals so dont factor it in
runs, hrs, rbis, Sb, AVG, OBA

I need the most help in HRs and RBIs and avg

leaning towards giving up on Desmond -

I agree with Pitbull that Tapia is starting to cut into Desmond’s PT. From that list, it’s him, Joc or Piscotty Too Hotty. Probably Desmond.

[Sour Masher]

I ant to say Desmond, but would they really sit a guy they are paying so much?

[revo]

Maybe Desmond is breaking out of it, 2 triples tonight.