Help evaluating keepers in 10-team, NL-only 5x5

[Falcon]

Whittling down my keeper list in my 10-team, 5x5, NL-only, dynasty draft (no $$). Looking for input from the Pen:

Right now set with:

Goldschmidt
Bellinger
Nola
Myers

Others to consider:

Dahl *
Castillo *
A. Rosario *
W. Ramos *
Nimmo
Escobar
Lamb
W. Davis
Desmond *
Senzel *
Happ

* Leaning toward keeping

[harmon]

Assuming you are allowed 10 keepers?

I would keep Nimmo and Escobar over Desmond.

[madducks]

Dahl *
Castillo *
A. Rosario *
W. Ramos *
Nimmo
Senzel *

[joncarlos]

Probably not keeping Desmond. Do you start 2 catchers?

If it's a dynasty I want to find a place for Senzel.

Even in a dynasty though, I really like Davis. I think he's got the job and even if his ratios aren't elite, he'll get a ton of saves.

[Gregg]

Dahl *
Castillo *
A. Rosario *
W. Ramos *
Nimmo
Senzel *

I agree with this. Nimmo is a must keep for me this year.

[Fresno Bob]

off your keeper list, I assume you are not playing for this year. What's the trade market like. Could you move Davis for something real (assuming he's getting saves) later in the year if you kept him?

[cavebird]

I agree with this. Nimmo is a must keep for me this year.

I agree with Gregg. Nimmo easily over Desmond. Davis, too, but Nimmo over Davis. If it isn't a two catcher league, Nimmo and Davis over Desmond and Ramos.