Fisher/Morton/Healy/Richards for CDavis/CGomez/Tanaka?

[overkill94]

10-team AL-only keeper league 5x5 (OBP) - we can keep up to 10

In first place with a slim lead, need help on offense (especially steals), already first in all pitching categories except ERA. Would you make the following trade?

Derek Fisher - $10/2 years left on his contract
Ryon Healy - $9/2
Charlie Morton - $1/2
Garrett Richards - $9/2

for

Chris Davis
Masahiro Tanaka
Carlos Gomez - $20/2 (only one with a contract even close to being keepable)

Preseason this would've been vetoed but with how bad Tanaka and Davis have been it gives me pause. Morton's the only one on that list that would truly hurt to give up keeper-wise since Healy's low OBP offsets his power and the other two are fairly marginal. Gomez would hopefully help me gain a few points in steals and if Davis/Tanaka return to form it could help me in ERA/HR/RBI/OBP.

Thoughts?

[revo]

Tanaka's been really good since the end of June: 3.00 ERA, 1.00 WHIP and a 10.26 K/9 rate.

If you're in first and you want to win, I don't see how this can hurt unless you think you can find a better deal.

[cool hand]

No. Morton is then gem of the bunch and I don't know that you're gaining much. Era is the area Tanaka most questionable.

[overkill94]

I'm just not sure Davis and Tanaka are better than Healy and Morton at this point. I'm trying to just make it Fisher for Gomez (which is what we tentatively had in place originally) but he seems to be holding out for more.

[revo]

Tanaka to the DL with shoulder inflammation

[Kevin Seitzer]

What are the odds that Derek Fisher steals more bases than Carlos Gomez the rest of the year?

[Hornsby]

I'm just not sure Davis and Tanaka are better than Healy and Morton at this point. I'm trying to just make it Fisher for Gomez (which is what we tentatively had in place originally) but he seems to be holding out for more.

If it's a keeper league, no way I give up Fisher for Gonzo...no way.

[overkill94]

Really? That high on Fisher?

[Hornsby]

Really? That high on Fisher?

Probably less high on Gomez rather than anything else...although I do think that Fisher has been aggressively promoted, and really hasn't failed up to this point.

[overkill94]

I picked up Fisher off waivers so I don't have much allegiance to him. Plus, he would be at $10 for the first two years and then $15 if you wanted to extend him for the last two years - not much profit if you ask me.