My little PONY keepers

[heyelander]

This team looks much sadder than the past couple of years. Perhaps I shouldn't have left $24 on the table last year. Who's out? Would you go in with less than 10?

15 team mixed, standard 5x5, 2 catchers.
o = option year, +$5. G = gone in that year

Kris Bryant $5 o18
Bogaerts $5 o17 - Extend? How many?
J Bradley $1 o17 - Extend? How many?
Zobrist $8 o18
Votto $30 o17
Hanley $19 o18

G Cole $15 g18
K Herrera $5 o18

Others:
Nola $5 o18
T Joseph $5 o18
B Phillips $9 o18

[DMT]

Doesn't look that bad. I'd extend both one year and toss Phillips back.

[heyelander]

Doesn't look that bad. I'd extend both one year and toss Phillips back.

I've got cheap expiring contracts on both Dozier and C Hamels, and a decent one on Sale.

2 years ago was even nicer. I had a great team that I parlayed into a 4th place finish.

[Teenwolf]

I've got cheap expiring contracts on both Dozier and C Hamels, and a decent one on Sale.

2 years ago was even nicer. I had a great team that I parlayed into a 4th place finish.

I believe in Dozier to come close to reproducing his 2016 numbers. He's also a candidate to get moved to a better run producing lineup mid-season, and if he's under $30, could become a keeper for an extra season or two. I own him myself at $28 in an AL league, and these have been my personal conclusions. That 2nd half is insane.

Hamels and Sale are tough calls. I've read up and down reports on both.

So, what prices are these 3? I believe Tommy Joseph $5 is your 9th, but you should consider Dozier at a discount on draft price as your 10th.

[heyelander]

I believe in Dozier to come close to reproducing his 2016 numbers. He's also a candidate to get moved to a better run producing lineup mid-season, and if he's under $30, could become a keeper for an extra season or two. I own him myself at $28 in an AL league, and these have been my personal conclusions. That 2nd half is insane.

Hamels and Sale are tough calls. I've read up and down reports on both.

So, what prices are these 3? I believe Tommy Joseph $5 is your 9th, but you should consider Dozier at a discount on draft price as your 10th.

Opps, sorry, I meant they expired this year, so they are gone. Last year, and especially the year before the team looked much nice going into the auction... then I did things like leave $24 on the table.

[madducks]

Doesn't look that bad. I'd extend both one year and toss Phillips back.

I agree with this.

[chancellor]

I'm with the consensus on all but the Bogaerts extension. This looks like a high inflation league, so I'd extend him two years instead of one.