Puig or Pollock for 10th and final keeper?

10 Team H2H points league. Keep 10. My other 9 are:

Goldy
Altuve
Tulo
Upton
Kershaw
Kluber
J. Zimmerman
Lester
Rosenthal

Scoring:
http://games.espn.go...leagueId=180071

Pollock scored 688 points last season and Puig managed 232 in only 285 AB's

[Hornsby]

Yeah, I'd say Pollock pretty easily, even though I think that Puig has a nice bounceback season.

I might consider Puig over Zimmerman though...

[Sour Masher]

I think this is closer than it looks, because I think Pollock will regress and Puig has the potential to perform way better. But Pollock is still the safer bet. I mean, the hope for Puig is that he is as valuable as what Pollock was last year, but that is far from a good bet given his maturity issues. It is not impossible that Puig outperforms Pollock in 2016, but I wouldn't put an even money bet on it. I'd keep Pollock.

Of course, another option is tossing back a pitcher and keeping both. In a 10 team league, you can gamble on Puig without it hurting you too much. I'm not a huge fan of Zimmerman. In a league that shallow, I think tossing him back to keep Puig makes sense.

[mjl]

agree with both of the above. I'd throw back Zimmermann also.

[revo]

agree with both of the above. I'd throw back Zimmermann also.

Agreed -- keep Puig & Pollock and toss Zimmerman (or even Rosenthal).

[Don Quixote]

I'd keep both over Zimmerman, Lester, or Rosenthal. I agree that Zimmerman is the most droppable of those pitchers.

This.

[Gregg]

I would keep both and drop Zim as well.