Who would you rather have for 2011/2012, Jennings or Aroldis?

[amcg]

With particular emphasis on 2012, in a standard mixed 5x5 roto would you rather have Desmond Jennings or Aroldis Chapman?

[wannabegriffey]

Strong on base and a LOT of speed...should be up and playing full time barring injury sometime this season, Jennings MUST be the choice as chapman is a pitcher.

[schlesinj]

Is Chapman a starter or RP? Is he a closer? Who knows, go with the hitter.

[amcg]

Well that's two for Jennings...

[B-Fly]

I think Chapman may edge him out for fantasy value in 2010 just as a high-K, vulture win/save RP, since there's a decent chance the Rays go primarily with Damon, Upton, Zobrist and Joyce this season. But if you've got a particular emphasis on 2012, I think the balance tips to Jennings.

[The Dane]

If both players reach the pinnacle of their promise, then Chapman is the pick. If both players fall into the statistical probabilities of their positions, then Jennings is the pick. Take the hitter.

[Moonlight J]

If both players reach the pinnacle of their promise, then Chapman is the pick. If both players fall into the statistical probabilities of their positions, then Jennings is the pick. Take the hitter.

came here to say this