PONY Keeper list help

[joncarlos]

This list is quite a mess, with all the off-season closer movement, some tough extension decisions, and a lot of guys that look similar in value.

18-team mixed league, standard 5x5, probably about 20-25 percent inflation, maybe a bit more. We can keep up to 10, there is no minimum. The first 5 are pretty easy but there are some extension questions. After that I'm not sure.

SP Hellickson $5 o13 (o13 means decide on option before 2013)
C Santana $11 O12
OF Bruce $5 o11 - extend to $10 g12? $15 g13? (g12 means signed through 2012)
OF Gardner $5 o11 - extend to $10 g12?
1B K Morales $12 o11 - extend to $17 g12?
----
SP Medlen $1 o12
SP J Chacin $1 o12
RP Storen $5 o13
RP Nathan $9 o12
RP Venters $5 o12
RP Uehara $5 o12
OF Nolan Reimold $5 o11
SS Pennington $5 o12
RP H Street $16 o12
SP Arrieta $5 o12
SP Chris Tillman $5 o12
RP Mike Adams $1 o12
OF G Parra $1 o12
SP CM Wang $1 o12

[axman]

I'd extend Bruce for 2 years, Morales for 1 and Gardner for 1 also (tough call though)
I'd rank the rest:
1. Chacin
2. Storen
3. Nathan
4. Venters
5. Street
6. Adams
7. Pennington
8. Uehara

[Gregg]

I pretty much agree with axman, except I do not give Morales a raise. I take the profit. If you feel compelled to give him a raise than I take a year off Bruce.

The pitching order seems right to me.